Truman Bethurum and the Planet Clarion: A Critical Analysis of the 1954 Contact Claims

---

Truman Bethurum’s alleged encounters with beings from a mysterious planet called Clarion represent one of the most colorful chapters in early UFO contact history. His 1954 book “Aboard a Flying Saucer” chronicled what he claimed were eleven separate contacts with extraterrestrial beings, igniting both fascination and skepticism during the golden age of flying saucer reports. This detailed analysis examines Bethurum’s claims, their credibility, historical context, and lasting impact on UFO culture and discourse.

The Life and Claims of Truman Bethurum

Truman Bethurum was born on August 21, 1898, in Gavalin, California, and lived until May 21, 1969¹². With minimal formal education, he worked primarily as a blue-collar laborer throughout his life, taking jobs as a mechanic, truck driver, and construction worker¹. In the early 1950s, Bethurum was employed as a truck driver and mechanic on a road-building crew in the Nevada desert, where his alleged extraterrestrial encounters would begin².

According to Bethurum’s account, his first contact occurred on July 27, 1952, near Mormon Mesa in Nevada³⁴. As he described it, he had been searching for seashells on a hilltop before falling asleep in his truck. He was awakened by strange murmuring sounds and discovered he was surrounded by eight to ten small men, all approximately 4’8” to 5’ tall³. These beings, who initially spoke in an unintelligible language before switching to “perfect English,” escorted him to their spacecraft³.

Bethurum described the craft as resembling burnished stainless steel, approximately 300 feet in diameter and six yards deep at its center³⁵. Aboard this vessel, he claimed to have met the ship’s captain, Aura Rhanes, whom he characterized as a beautiful female with olive complexion and jet black hair¹. According to his testimony, Captain Rhanes appeared to be in her 40s while Bethurum himself was in his 50s at the time¹.

The extraterrestrials allegedly came from a planet called “Clarion,” which Bethurum claimed existed within our solar system but remained undiscovered because it was perpetually hidden from Earth by the Moon¹². The Clarionites, as Bethurum called them, reportedly expressed concern about Earth’s nuclear capabilities and potential for planetary destruction¹. He also described them as smaller than humans, with 1,000-year lifespans, and remarkably, as “good Christians who attended church every Sunday”⁶.

Bethurum initially shared his extraordinary experiences at a flying saucer convention at Giant Rock in 1952, followed by an abbreviated account in the fanzine “Saucers” the following year¹. His comprehensive narrative was published in his 1954 book “Aboard a Flying Saucer,” which brought him significant attention in UFO circles¹⁷.

From Contact to Cult Following

Following the publication of his book, Bethurum developed a substantial following within contactee culture. In 1955, he claimed that Aura Rhanes had advised him to establish what was called the “Sanctuary of Thought”¹. This spiritual center eventually opened near Prescott, Arizona, where Bethurum continued as an active lecturer and exponent of the contactee perspective until his death¹.

Bethurum’s newfound celebrity included numerous interviews, lectures, book signings, and appearances on radio and television, including two notable guest spots on “The Betty White Show,” a nationally broadcast NBC program². His claims had significant personal consequences as well—his second marriage reportedly ended due to his wife’s outrage over his tales of the “gorgeous Space Sister” Aura Rhanes⁷.

Credibility Assessment

Any thorough analysis of Bethurum’s claims must consider both the credibility of the witness and the plausibility of the experiences he described.

Witness Background and Reliability

Bethurum had limited formal education and worked primarily in blue-collar occupations throughout his life¹. While this background doesn’t automatically undermine his credibility, it is worth noting that unlike some UFO witnesses with technical or scientific expertise, Bethurum lacked specialized knowledge that might have enhanced the technical details of his account.

Interestingly, one source indicates that unlike most road-crew members, Bethurum “moonlighted as a fortune teller and spiritual advisor”⁶. This prior involvement with paranormal or metaphysical practices raises questions about whether he might have been predisposed to interpreting experiences through a supernatural lens or had pre-existing interests in extraordinary phenomena.

The personal cost Bethurum endured—including the dissolution of his marriage and potential ridicule—suggests he maintained his story despite significant consequences. While this could indicate sincerity, it could equally reflect commitment to a fabrication that had become central to his identity and livelihood.

Scientific Plausibility

Several aspects of Bethurum’s account strain scientific credibility:

1. The planet Clarion was described as existing in our solar system but remaining hidden behind the Moon¹². This explanation contradicts basic celestial mechanics, as no planet could maintain such a precise orbital relationship with the Moon relative to Earth observers. As one source notes, “Much of the critique originated from the scientific analysis of the impossibility of the existence of a planet such as Clarion that remained hidden from Earth due to its following an orbit similar to but beyond the Moon”¹.
2. The Clarionites were described with remarkably human and culturally specific characteristics—they spoke English, were described as looking like “Latin types,” and were said to be Christian church-goers¹⁶³. These anthropocentric details suggest projection of human cultural elements rather than encounters with a truly alien civilization.
3. Bethurum claimed to possess “physical evidence of extraterrestrial existence” given to him by Captain Rhanes, but apparently never produced this evidence for objective examination².
4. The description of Aura Rhanes as an attractive, humanoid female captain aligns more closely with human romantic fantasy than with what might be expected of an independently evolved extraterrestrial species.

Contextual Analysis: The Contactee Movement

Bethurum’s claims emerged during a specific cultural moment and must be understood within that context. The early 1950s saw a proliferation of claimed contacts with benevolent “Space Brothers” following George Adamski’s highly publicized accounts.

Timing and Influences

Bethurum is often described as “the second of the classic 1950s ‘contactees’”⁶, with his revelations appearing “fairly directly inspired by his immediate forerunner, George Adamski”⁶. This timing is significant, as it suggests Bethurum’s narrative emerged not in isolation but within an already-established framework of claimed alien contacts.

The modern UFO phenomenon had begun in 1947 with Kenneth Arnold’s famous sighting near Mount Rainier, which gained widespread media attention⁸. Following this, George Adamski became well-known for his claims of meeting friendly Venusians with warnings about nuclear weapons. Bethurum’s similar narrative—featuring benevolent aliens concerned about nuclear destruction—shows notable parallels to these preceding accounts.

Pattern of Contactee Claims

Bethurum followed a pattern common to many contactees of this period. As one source notes, “Most contactees of this period became (or already were) leaders of religious cults, including George Adamski, George Van Tassel, Daniel Fry, George King and many others. Bethurum followed the same pattern, quitting his job and telling followers—immediately after the publication of his book—that the space people had commanded him to create a religious commune”⁶.

This pattern raises questions about potential motivations beyond simply reporting an extraordinary experience. The transition from claiming alien contact to founding spiritual organizations with oneself as the central authority appears consistently across multiple contactees of this era.

Skepticism and Counterarguments

Bethurum’s claims have faced substantial criticism from both the scientific community and even within UFO research circles.

Scientific Impossibility

The most damaging criticism centers on the scientific impossibility of the planet Clarion’s existence. The laws of celestial mechanics make it physically impossible for a planet to remain perpetually hidden behind the Moon from Earth’s perspective. This fundamental problem undermines the foundational premise of Bethurum’s narrative.

Professional UFO Researcher Dismissal

It’s noteworthy that even within the UFO research community, Bethurum’s claims received significant skepticism. As one source states, “Serious UFO researchers and investigators dismissed Bethurum and the other 1950s contactees as charlatans and con-artists”². This assessment from individuals otherwise open to UFO phenomena suggests Bethurum’s claims failed to meet even the standards of evidence applied within ufology.

Psychological and Sociological Explanations

From a psychological perspective, Bethurum’s claims could represent various phenomena—from vivid dreams or hallucinations to conscious fabrication. The deeply personal nature of his claimed encounters, featuring an attractive female alien captain, suggests possible psychological elements at play.

Sociologically, the timing of his claims during the early Cold War, when anxieties about nuclear annihilation were widespread, reflects broader societal concerns. The Space Brothers’ warnings about nuclear weapons mirrored real-world anxieties about atomic destruction, potentially providing comfort through the fantasy of advanced beings who might intervene to save humanity from itself.

Cultural Impact and Legacy

Despite scientific implausibility and widespread skepticism, Bethurum’s claims had a meaningful impact on UFO culture and continue to be discussed today.

Influence on Contactee Culture

As one of the earliest and most prominent contactees, Bethurum helped establish key elements of contactee narratives that would persist for decades. The “Space Brothers” archetype—benevolent, human-like aliens concerned about Earth’s development—became a staple of UFO culture, providing a more optimistic counternarrative to the often-frightening depictions of aliens in science fiction media of the time⁹.

The year 1952, when Bethurum claimed his encounters began, is described as “a watershed year for UFO interactions and the Contactee movement”⁹. This movement represented a significant shift from simply sighting unidentified craft to claims of meaningful communication with their occupants.

Institutional Expression

The Sanctuary of Thought, which Bethurum established near Prescott, Arizona, represented an institutional expression of the spiritual teachings he claimed to have received from the Clarionites¹. While the sanctuary did not survive his death, it exemplifies how contactee claims could evolve into organized spiritual movements with dedicated followers.

Media Attention and Public Awareness

Following the publication of “Aboard a Flying Saucer,” Bethurum achieved a measure of celebrity. His book “sold well and Bethurum gave many interviews and lectures, attended book signings and made several appearances on radio and television”². His appearances on “The Betty White Show” brought his claims to a mainstream American audience, expanding the reach of his narrative beyond UFO enthusiast circles².

Government Interest

There are indications that Bethurum’s activities drew official attention. Documents available through the Black Vault reveal that the FBI was aware of Bethurum’s claims and monitored his activities to some degree¹⁰. This official interest reflects the broader concern of government agencies about the potential impact of UFO claims during the Cold War era.

Continued Cultural Relevance

Although not as famous as some other contactees like George Adamski, Bethurum’s story continues to generate interest. The podcast “Astonishing Legends” dedicated multiple episodes to examining his claims in 2023, indicating ongoing fascination with this case⁹⁵. A YouTube video titled “The Incredible Close Encounters of Truman Bethurum” from 2018 further demonstrates this continued interest⁴.

Occult Connections and Broader Patterns

Recent analyses have noted connections between the contactee movement and occult traditions. As one source observes, “there is a much-overlooked aspect of some of the personalities involved in this generation of heralds – a fair number of them had ties to occult beliefs and practices”⁹. From “Aleister Crowley’s magick and Jack Parsons to the wackier exploits of George Hunt Williamson,” there appears to be a historical thread connecting certain UFO claims to older occult traditions⁹.

While Bethurum himself isn’t specifically identified as having strong occult connections, his positioning within a movement that had such connections provides additional context for understanding the nature and appeal of his claims.

Follow-up Research Possibilities

Several areas warrant further investigation for those seeking a deeper understanding of this case:

1. Bethurum’s Other Writings: Beyond “Aboard a Flying Saucer,” Bethurum authored other works including “The Voice of the Planet Clarion”⁶, which might reveal evolution in his narrative or additional details not covered in his first book.
2. Contemporary Accounts: Contemporary newspaper reports, such as those in the Redondo Beach “Daily Breeze” (September 25, 1953) and the Los Angeles Daily News article by Matt Weinstock (October 7, 1953), could provide valuable context for how Bethurum’s claims were initially received⁶⁹.
3. Sanctuary of Thought Records: Any surviving documentation from Bethurum’s “Sanctuary of Thought” could illuminate how his claimed extraterrestrial encounters translated into spiritual teachings and organizational structure.
4. Government Documents: More comprehensive examination of government records, including those from the FBI, Air Force, and potentially the CIA, might reveal additional information about official interest in Bethurum’s claims during the Cold War.
5. Witness Testimonies: Accounts from Bethurum’s contemporaries, including family members, co-workers, and associates, could provide insights into his character, behavior, and possible motivations during the period of his claimed contacts.

Conclusion

Truman Bethurum’s claimed encounters with beings from the planet Clarion represent a significant case study in early contactee history. While his accounts contain numerous elements that strain scientific credibility, their impact on UFO culture and discourse is undeniable. Whether viewed as genuine experiences, psychological phenomena, or deliberate fabrications, Bethurum’s claims emerge from and reflect the complex cultural landscape of Cold War America.

The scientifically impossible orbital mechanics of Clarion, the suspiciously human characteristics of the aliens, and the timing of Bethurum’s claims following other contactee accounts all suggest significant reasons for skepticism. Yet the personal costs Bethurum bore and the lasting influence of his narrative demonstrate the power such claims can have, regardless of their factual basis.

From a historical perspective, Bethurum’s case illuminates how extraordinary claims function within culture, reflecting broader societal concerns while simultaneously offering alternative narratives that address those concerns. The enduring fascination with his story, even decades after his death, speaks to the persistent human interest in the possibility of contact with intelligence beyond Earth—and the complex ways in which such possibilities are imagined, articulated, and received.

References

The sources used in this analysis include encyclopedia entries, academic analyses, podcasts, videos, and historical documents, providing a multi-faceted perspective on Bethurum’s claims and their context.

Sources and Bibliography

Multiple primary and secondary sources detail Bethurum’s claims, from his own writings to later analyses by UFO researchers and skeptics. His 1954 book “Aboard a Flying Saucer” remains the definitive account of his alleged experiences⁷, while contemporary newspaper accounts such as those in the Redondo Beach “Daily Breeze” documented his claims as they first became public⁶.

For those interested in deeper research, FBI files on Truman Bethurum available through the Black Vault provide insights into how government agencies monitored contactee claims during this period¹⁰, while recent discussions such as the two-part examination by “Astonishing Legends” podcast offer contemporary perspectives on his claims⁹⁵.

⁂

^{162111279348131051415161718192021222324252627282930313233}

1. https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/bethurum-truman-1898-1969 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸ ↩⁹ ↩¹⁰ ↩¹¹ ↩¹² ↩¹³ ↩¹⁴ ↩¹⁵ ↩¹⁶

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truman_Bethurum ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸ ↩⁹ ↩¹⁰

3. https://the-wanderling.com/bethurum.html ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶

4. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VLcRuUnCVg ↩ ↩² ↩³

5. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFWRmI-mMB8 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴

6. https://en-academic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/2355240 ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸ ↩⁹ ↩¹⁰

7. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13457598-aboard-a-flying-saucer ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴

8. https://www.cracked.com/article_30617_back-in-the-day-everybody-was-talking-to-aliens-thanks-to-one-scammer.html ↩ ↩²

9. https://astonishinglegends.com/al-podcasts/2023/24/09/ep-266-bethurum-part-2-ufos-and-the-occult ↩ ↩² ↩³ ↩⁴ ↩⁵ ↩⁶ ↩⁷ ↩⁸

10. https://documents2.theblackvault.com/documents/fbifiles/paranormal/trumanbethurum-fbi1.pdf ↩ ↩² ↩³

11. https://sdonline.org/issue/42/flying-saucers-are-real-us-navy-unidentified-flying-objects-and-national-security-state ↩

12. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/17346.html.images ↩

13. https://skepticalinquirer.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/29/2019/03/SI-MJ-10.pdf ↩

14. https://www.biblio.com/booksearch/author/bethurum-truman/title/aboard-a-flying-saucer ↩

15. https://www.abebooks.co.uk/signed-first-edition/Aboard-Flying-Saucer-Truman-Bethurum-DeVorss/30220861373/bd ↩

16. https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/AD0688332.pdf ↩

17. https://soundcloud.com/mark-russell-bell/truman-bethurum-interview-1954 ↩

18. https://audioboom.com/posts/8372629-bethurum-part-2-ufos-and-the-occult ↩

19. https://www.etsy.com/listing/980332919/vintage-books-aboard-a-flying-saucer ↩

20. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contactee ↩

21. https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/145975475773?chn=ps\&_ul=GB\&mkevt=1\&mkcid=28\&google_free_listing_action=view_item ↩

22. https://web.archive.org/web/20060206034919/http:/www.xdream.freeserve.co.uk/Space People/TrumanB.htm ↩

23. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_Prophecy_Fails ↩

24. https://www.reddit.com/r/aliens/comments/pme5ia/has_anyone_here_heard_the_name_aura_rains/ ↩

25. https://www.mauritiustimes.com/mt/why-are-people-starting-to-believe-in-ufos-again/ ↩

26. https://www.biblio.com/book/aboard-flying-saucer-fiction-true-personal/d/1341391054 ↩

27. https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/forget-moving-canada-theres-room-moon/ ↩

28. https://www.abebooks.com/signed-first-edition/Aboard-Flying-Saucer–Non-Fiction-True/30719796285/bd ↩

29. https://journal.fi/scripta/article/view/67234/27532 ↩

30. https://vault.fbi.gov/truman-bethurum/Truman Bethurum Part 01 (Final) ↩

31. https://web2.ph.utexas.edu/~coker2/index.files/sbrothers.shtml ↩

32. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/long_reads/world-ufo-day-extraterrestrial-aliens-us-marines-navy-a8977241.html ↩

33. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Investigations_Committee_On_Aerial_Phenomena ↩